Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
All Pro Tire All Pro Automotive doesn't just sell tires. We provide the SERVICE your vehicle needs to maximize the value and mileage of the tires we sell. At All Pro Automotive we give our customers the individual attention you deserve. All Pro Automotive is your headquarters for tires and automotive service. Founded in 1978, we have a longstanding reputation with customers in Lyme/Old Lyme, CT, Old Saybrook, CT, East Lyme, CT, and surrounding areas. Our staff includes seasoned technicians who provide the auto repair, tire, and regular maintenance services your vehicle requires.
Services
At All Pro Automotive, you are more than just a customer. Since 1978, Jim Graybill and his sons Jeff and Dave Graybill have provided you with the individualized service that you know and trust. We do more than just sell tires. Our pledge to you is to provide your vehicle with the best care possible to get the most value and mileage out of the tires you buy from us.
Here at All Pro Automotive we want your car or truck to look its best. We also want you to feel good driving your car or truck down the streets in Old Lyme, CT or Old Saybrook, CT, so that is why having a nice set of wheels or rims is crucial. The selection of wheels and rims here at All Pro Automotive is second to none.
Here at All Pro Automotive, we carry many name brand tires to serve Old Lyme, CT, Old Saybrook, CT, East Lyme, CT and Essex, CT, CT. Our tire prices are some of the lowest around and we have the Old Lyme, CT tire service to back up our tires for as long as you own your car. Not sure on which Old Lyme, CT tires are right for your car?
At Cooper, we talk tires every day, and we understand that the four tires on your vehicle are what keep you connected to the road, playing a crucial role in how your vehicle handles, and in keeping you safe on your travels. As an American company since 1914, our focus is on making quality tires that will perform well and last for thousands of miles.
Reviews (16)
Write a Review
Iamvanica
Jun 15, 2022
Hung up while I was asking a question. I called back and was placed on hold with out so much as a hello. Once call was answered. I asked about a 6 mile tow. Was told out of area and then the guy hung up on me again.
Stacey Guevara
Jun 10, 2022
Jeff was very helpful and was able to work me in the schedule even though they were very busy
Jacob Ruffcorn
Mar 25, 2022
Was very impressed with the service today and will be going here from now on for all auto service. Really liked how they let me go back in the shop and see the issue for myself.
Amber DeVito
Mar 17, 2022
The team here at All Pro is fantastic! They are quick and efficient at getting the cars in and out. Everyone is friendly and knowledgeable. I trust these guys to tell me what I need to know about my vehicle. I will be coming back for all my service needs! Services: Oil change, Brakes
Regina Rafailov
Mar 06, 2022
Phenomenal service & great guys, that go above and beyond! Super organized and extremely quick. I'm a NYER who on the way home blew my tire - made it off an exit, where they came to the rescue! Since I was near the shop, they came, removed, replaced, and brought me back in one piece! Thanks Gentlemen, you were life savors!
Alexander Klose
Feb 24, 2022
Jeff and the Team at All Pro was amazing. I had a serious issue with my 98' Explorer exhaust that was coming into the cabin. They were able to order a part for my older vehicle, it came in a day, and make recommendations from some other fixes that we agreed to. Everything was done very quickly and on budget! I know how difficult it can be working on an older New England vehicle and I was extremely impressed with the professionalism and customer care. My Explorer sounds and feels 15 years younger!
Dawn Kelley
Jan 17, 2022
I would give them six stars if I could! I am both a single woman and up in years which means I could be taken advantage of easily. In all my visits, Dave has never suggested an upsell even when I did. They are friendly and efficient. Even with my last visit, I asked Dave, when the shop was closed he was still on the phone with me, if my spare tire could be filled, he said just ask the attendant tomorrow because the shop is closed.

The next day I picked up my car New Year's Eve day, forgetting about my spare tire, and on the way home I noticed the tire light was off, He had it done for me. He went out of his way for me and I can feel safe on the road now. I highly recommend them and I am tough to please.
James Ferrara
Dec 28, 2021
Great, old school automotive shop. They treat everyone with respect, courtesy and appreciation. Excellent technicians. Would highly recommend. Services: Oil change, Tyres, Wheel alignment
Lewis Mostowy
Dec 22, 2021
Jeff and his crew are simply the best in the area at car and customer service based on my 15 years of experience with All Pro. And that ranges from an oil change to a motor replacement.
Eric Sirois
Dec 02, 2021
Very helpful - I really appreciated the honest appraisal of what my car needed.
Dave Padilla
Oct 20, 2021
Honest and reliable. I've had many services done here. Latest was installing after market running boards on my '17 Ford Explorer. They did a great job, on time and on budget.
John Bailey
Oct 16, 2021
I had a tire balance issue that two other repair facilities could not correct, In fact they just made it worse. All Pro Automotive took care of it. Not only do they have a Road Force wheel balance but apparently the tech knows how to use it. Great job!
Jess Ryan
Sep 07, 2021
I just wanted to thank the owners of this business for their time, professionalism, and kindness in a stressful situation. They really helped my father and I out in a time of need. My car constantly had something wrong with it as it is an older one. It is an hour away from me but I wouldn't go anywhere else. They worked with my schedule and with money.

They even gave me a loaner car as they fixed mine! So thank you.especially to Jeff, Dave, and the mechanics. You are all amazing and I truly appreciate you! Great business and I will be spreading the word! Much love!
Aileen Cahill
Aug 29, 2021
We have been delighted with All Pro for the past 6 years. They are organized, professional and reasonable business people. It's a pleasure to support a locally owned second generation family business Services: Air conditioning, Oil change, General repairs & maintenance, Tyres, Electrical repair
Danielle St Germain
Jul 22, 2021
My check engine light came on a couple days before a trip I had to make to the Cape for my father's celebration of life. I called panicked and All-Pro scheduled me in and took care of a cylinder repair in the back of my engine. I was off on my trip on time and back on the road safely! I am so grateful I can count on All-Pro to be there for me!
Richard Bailey
Jun 28, 2021
All Pro Automotive is the absolute BEST of the best. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. I have never not been satisfied with their customer service. The only place I know of in CT with a Roadforce wheel balance machine. Even if I found a another place closer, I'm not sure I'd go. The customer service alone I worth the 1.5 hour commute. In a time where customer service seems to be a fairytale.its extremely comforting to see its very much real. I Highly recommend All Pro Automotive, you will not be disappointed.